After Abu Dhabi, the West Finally Starts Listening to the Russians

After Abu Dhabi, the West Finally Starts Listening to the Russians

(Editor.) Since 2022, the heads of state of EU countries have refused to talk to Russia. They prefer to supply weapons and help train Ukrainian soldiers. But now that talks between the US and Moscow are imminent, they suddenly want to sit at the table with them. How does that fit together? Patrick Lawrence, our columnist from the USA, has been thinking about this – and he suspects that Steve Witkoff plays a special role. (cm)

There is not much good to say about Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner, the New York real estate entrepreneurs who are acting incompetently as „special envoys“ of President Trump. While both appear to be good at maximizing profits in the Manhattan real estate market, neither demonstrates suitability for diplomatic or statesmanlike affairs. I cannot say what Kushner is doing, except that he speaks for the Zionist state in the White House committees under Trump. As for Witkoff, he seems to have a habit that is now proving to be a virtue. Like the man he serves as frontman for, he tends to agree with the person who last spoke to him. It can be a good thing if the person who last spoke to him has something useful to say. 

This now appears to be confirmed, as negotiations resume in a multifaceted effort to reach an agreement that ends the war in Ukraine and – most importantly– brings about the lasting agreement between Russia and the West that Moscow has long sought. 

Last week, Witkoff, accompanied by Kushner, called the first talks since February in which Russia and Ukraine sat at the same mahogany table. These took place in Abu Dhabi and covered a wide range of topics: Russia’s security demands, a territorial agreement in eastern Ukraine, a ceasefire, a regulation to include Europeans in future negotiations – I will come back to this last perspective shortly.

Not much emerged from the two days that Americans, Russians and Ukrainians spent in the capital of the United Arab Emirates – at least according to Western media reports. A ceasefire is of course out of the question, as Moscow has made clear from the beginning; Kyiv is merely insisting on it to provoke further Russian rejection – a tiresome propaganda exercise. Neither the Russians nor the Ukrainians show great enthusiasm for a compromise on the territorial issue, although The  Telegraph, citing „US officials“, reported the exact opposite, a few days before the talks in Abu Dhabi. „Both sides have shown a little flexibility behind closed doors, and therefore we will begin the discussion about what that might look like“, the London daily newspaper reported on the 9th. November from Washington. 

A little flexibility. Expressed behind closed doors. According to a US official. It’s hard to say how to interpret something like this, but I don’t see it as much more than an attempt to get things moving, as the Americans say. If you read the above quote carefully, the Americans are talking about negotiating.

However, I foresee a significant turn for the better in the days leading up to and since Abu Dhabi. In a subtle, if not entirely open, way, Washington and the European capitals finally seem to accept that it is time to acknowledge what Moscow calls for as an indispensable part of any agreement to end the Ukraine crisis that it would be willing to sign. This seems to me to be the kind of breakthrough that –as we have read– the recently concluded talks were unable to achieve. 

Moscow’s demands are what President Putin and Sergey Lavrov, the Russian president’s foreign minister, describe as „the real causes“ of the war in Ukraine. The New York Times  described these in an article published over the weekend as „tough demands that have little prospect of being accepted by Ukraine and its European allies“. The Times  , as so often happens, is once again lagging behind. „Hard demands“ is yesterday’s rhetoric. Since Abu Dhabi, Moscow’s legitimate security interests have only been considered „tough“ in the Western press, and negotiations addressing them seem inevitable. 

■

Depending on how you count, Moscow has been striving for a comprehensive new security framework between Russia and the West since the beginning of the war in Ukraine almost five years ago – or since Putin personally tried to negotiate the two Minsk protocols after the US-backed coup in Kyiv almost 13 years ago, or since the collapse of the Soviet Union, which will become the 35th next month. The anniversary of this time. However, in terms of details and context, Moscow currently has little new information on the table.

It demands that the North Atlantic Alliance withdraw its troops from their current easternmost positions, that the alliance limit the use of missiles, that it guarantee Ukraine will not join NATO, and further restrictions regarding the size of the Ukrainian military. These are the most important of the long-standing and repeatedly expressed interests of the Russians in a new East-West security architecture.

In addition, there is the question of a territorial agreement between Moscow and Kyiv. In my estimation, however, a fundamental redesign of Russia’s relations with the US and Europe is a far higher priority for the Kremlin than the question of which borders will ultimately be drawn where on the maps of former eastern Ukraine. Currently, the Russians are in the same situation as the Iranians: As their confrontations with Western powers have intensified, neither side has an interest in returning to a status quo ante that isolates them and leaves them in a state of constant insecurity.

It can no longer be denied –apart from reports in Western media– that the Ukrainians have no chance of defeating the Russians, no matter how much support the Europeans waste on the corrupt regime in Kyiv. While this partly explains the West’s new willingness to gradually accommodate Moscow, I see this change as Witkoff’s hand. The Russians may not be the last to speak to him at any given time, but he quite obviously listens to them when they do. Witkoff wants to deliver „an agreement“ to his friend and employer, and Moscow has made it clear that there will be none until it meets the long-term interests of the Russian Federation. If that’s what’s needed,In order to bring Russian diplomats to the negotiating table, Witkoff has apparently closed down, so that’s exactly what needs to be brought into play: This is how I read the mindset of the New York real estate magnate and therefore also that of Trump.

I base this conclusion on  the frighteningly realistic plan that Witkoff published next week, a year ago, following extensive consultations with senior Russian officials. An East-West dialogue to resolve „all security issues“ (point 4), no further NATO enlargement, Ukrainian neutrality, a „general amnesty“: these were the most prominent points among the 28 points of the document. The second of these points summarizes the vision underlying this project (a strange word when one speaks of Witkoff, but I will leave it as is): „A comprehensive and all-encompassing [sic] non-aggression agreement will be concluded between Russia, Ukraine and Europe. All ambiguities of the last 30 years are considered resolved.“

The extent to which the plan took Moscow’s interests into account drew much criticism from Witkoff, and Kyiv and the Europeans did their best to undermine it. However, I counted this among the great advantages of the document. Witkoff and the man he acted for had already understood at the time what Europeans are only gradually realizing now: Russia has won the war or is well on its way to doing so, and any „agreement“ concluded with Moscow must reflect this.

„When US-led talks to end the war in Ukraine resumed in Abu Dhabi last week“, as The New York Times reported last Sunday, „the crucial question was whether Russia was prepared to make concessions after a nine-month break in negotiations.“ 

Completely turned upside down. After Abu Dhabi, the crucial question was and remains how long it will take for the Kyiv regime and its European backers to accept that the matter is lost and accordingly move towards an agreement that they have so far tried to prevent by all means. 

■

After refusing any contact with Moscow for the past five years –diplomacy itself was declared inadmissible–, the Europeans now want a place at the negotiating table in the talks that are to follow last week’s negotiations. „Europe will have a voice“, Volodymyr Zelenskyy declared boastfully after Abu Dhabi. There is „a window of opportunity“, the Ukrainian dictator added, to achieve peace by the end of the year.

I’m not waiting for it. 

Jared Kushner seems to have sparked this new enthusiasm. „We cannot conclude this agreement without the Europeans sitting at the table“, he declared after separate meetings with President Putin and Zelenskyy. But as it now turns out, Jared Kushner seems to have caused chaos. At the time of writing, it is unclear whether Europeans will even be granted such a place. The „Times“  from London reported on Monday that Moscow had so far rejected any idea of European participation. 

And who can blame the Russians? The European Union has repeatedly deceived them, particularly – but not only – when the Germans and French negotiated the Minsk Protocols dishonestly, without any intention of complying with them, as they later admitted. More recently, Europeans have pretended to support peace while eagerly prolonging the war and blaming Moscow for the suffering and bloodshed. 

The EU has been in turmoil since the momentum towards a negotiated solution began to emerge. Support for the Ukraine project is severely weakened among some members –Spain, Italy, Hungary–. Norway and Great Britain are not EU members. Eastern Europeans fear that „core Europe“ will betray them. „Under no circumstances will we allow new security rules for this part of the world to be established over our heads“, said Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk at the conclusion of talks in Abu Dhabi. That’s a well-known but foolish argument. While the traumas suffered by Eastern Europeans during the Soviet era must be acknowledged, they are the last people on whom the EU should seek sound assessments of Russia.

At a summit in Dublin last Friday, the EU decided to overcome its disunity by appointing no fewer than six representatives –from France, Germany, Italy, Poland, Great Britain and the political EU bureaucracy– to speak with the „European voice“ that Zelenskyy had mentioned in future talks with Russia, the USA and Ukraine. I don’t believe this will work, even if a change of heart is accepted in Moscow. What would this voice sound like and what would it say? What would their contribution be as one of four delegations at the negotiating table, while those disreputable peace activists representing the Trump regime are pushing for a reasonable agreement with the Russians? Will the EU now undergo a dramatic  about-face To work towards such an agreement? People would like to believe it, but I see no prospect of success here either.

This will prove to be a crucial moment for Europe, regardless of whether it takes a place at the negotiating table when talks on Ukraine resume or not. Either way, it will become clear what „Europe“ means, what it has made of itself, and what its future is likely to look like. I don’t expect anything good from it, although for many years I had hoped that the continent would develop into an independent power center whose voice others want to hear.

There are times when you can use events as a mirror to reflect realities that are otherwise not obvious – a practice I learned during my years as a correspondent. This is one such occasion. What does the sudden desire of Europeans to participate in a solution to the Ukraine crisis mean, after all these years of refusing diplomatic contacts with Moscow, if not the bitter realization that the Russians cannot be defeated in war and that ignoring their interests no longer offers any advantage?

■ 

President Trump will meet with Presidents Putin and Xi Jinping on Thursday on the sidelines of the annual meeting of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) – a rather insignificant forum that has never been able to agree on a name–. This will be a first: So far, these three have never participated in a summit meeting together.

Depending on which press you read, Trump will address the Iran crisis or not, and the war in Ukraine and the progress made towards a solution or not. Among the rather paranoid assessments of what will happen in Shenzhen, the industrial city on the southern coast of the mainland, is the assumption that the three heads of state –similar to Yalta– will decide on the future of Ukraine without coordinating with Ukraine. 

None of this is clear so far.

Trump has been significantly weakened since the Republicans’ disastrous performance in the congressional elections earlier this month. Alastair Crooke suggested in  a recently released podcast that what we call „Deep State“ is now trying to completely undermine the Trump regime, just as it did during his first term in office. How far this will go is also unclear, but disrupting Trump’s efforts to rebuild relations with Moscow was the main goal of this first attempt to sink his ship.

Shortly before the talks in Abu Dhabi, Trump made a remark that is worth a brief look. In an interview with Ross Douthat, a former New York Times columnist  and current CBS News correspondent, Trump reflected on the prospects for a swift resolution to the Ukraine crisis, saying: „I think we will get this done, and I think it will happen, and Ukraine will end up looking a little different.“

What will be achieved and when is never certain when Trump speaks at length. But I view his strikingly specific mention of new territorial arrangements as yet another mirror – one that reflects Steve Witkoff’s apparent progress towards a final agreement with the Russians, which Ukraine and the Europeans will ultimately have to accept.